Ikea Door Sensor - automatically controls nearest device

So Homey misidentifies an Aqara device as being from IKEA, and that’s Aqara’s fault? :thinking:

It sounds more like a fundamental issue with how Homey deals with IKEA and/or Aqara devices. I know that for Aqara, they had to implement certain changes deep in the Zigbee driver, and it wouldn’t surprise me of those changes are somehow causing a lot of these issues.

Well, I would have attributed the error more to the fact that Aqara does not disclose its data, forcing other developers to reverse-engineer it to find out how the parts actually work. This almost inevitably leads to errors, which could probably have been avoided with proper documentation.
If Aqara hadn’t been so idiosyncratic, the bug would probably never have occurred.

Whoever is responsible for it, the bug is absolutely unacceptable in a smart home (especially if it has existed for so long).

If this inevitably leads to errors, Homey shouldn’t have offered an app for it :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

Besides that, @Peter_Kawa has experience with these devices both with Homey and with better other Zigbee implementations, and came to the conclusion that this issue seems to be affecting Homey’s much more, which suggests it’s a Homey issue.

It’s a big red flag that you got that particular error with trying to re-pair an Aqara device, and one that Athom should take a closer look at.

1 Like

As mentioned earlier, this issue is on our radar. Aqara, IKEA, and we at Athom are all aware of it and are looking into what is causing this issue.

3 Likes

Is there any positive news on this front yet?

1 Like