Homey crashing out of nowhere regularly (red ring)

After major firmware updates, Homey (Early 2023) crashes regularly (like mentioned here Firmware 12.8.0 makes Homey crashing twice a day - #5 by SunBeech )– usually once or twice a day. This issue reoccurs every few months.

To get straight to the point: it’s poor memory cleanup management by Athom in the context of backups. Free memory drops a bit after backups and takes too long to recover.

The result: Homey crashes (red ring), no automatic reboot, no logs or timeline entries (there are no tools to help diagnose problems anyway), and it’s difficult to debug (the error sometimes occurs immediately, sometimes with a delay). I have around 60 apps installed, and often only 300–500 MB of RAM is left – but it should still run stably, what Homey normally does.

Support responds very slowly and has not made any changes so far (like we all know it), even though the issue has been reported multiple times (for over two years!). That alone says a lot about the direction Homey is heading.

Very simple possible improvements are just not being implemented: optional (switch for users?) reboot before or after backups, automatic memory cleanup immediately after backups, pre warning when memory gets low, short notices in the timeline or logs for users instead of blind crashes.

My current workaround: I now only create backups manually and restart Homey before and after each backup. That way, I can avoid the issue.

But this is sad, man. Such a great system, such a spirit of athom and where are we going now…?

3 Likes

I am experiencing exactly the same. Have been trying to disable some of the apps I have had problems with before, but no luck. I will now try to disable automatic backup to see if that helps. Thanks!

Please report to homey.app/support as well.

Unfortunately it did not help for me to turn off automatic updates…

Maybe you can tell how often that happens and if there is a pattern. Could you also take a look at the memory right after a reboot and again after a few hours?

What often helps is restoring from a backup — do you have one from before the bug started to occur?

I would activate Support with a debug number after the stall asap because that takes a little time..

Athom came along with a fix :smiling_face::smiling_face::tada:

A fix has been released in firmware version 12.9.0-rc14. Could you please enable experimental updates and update your Homey?
You can follow the instructions here:
https://support.homey.app/hc/en-us/articles/12199889665308-Enabling-experimental-updates-on-Homey-Pro-2023

==> So far no more crashes. What about you @Tobster ?

1 Like

I have noticed similar reboots too causing homey go offline and after a few days of monitoring I can see the memory filling up by circa 200 MB every night. Everything seems to point to issues with memory usage caused by backups or its processes.

I have disabled the backups and unsubscribed from them, it is better to just do a manual backup to usb anyway.

Don’t think I will update to the release candidate, waiting for Athom to come up with a stable.

12.9.0 is finally out of release candidate and into stable. I have jist updated, will see how memory behaves now.

Runs really stable without former problems… :four_leaf_clover::four_leaf_clover:

1 Like