Thanks Rob,
That’s some good information to know… I didn’t realise you knew so much about 433Mhz tech.
I’m surprised you didn’t bring those points up before in that last discussion we had about 433Mhz when I mentioned this $7 Chinese remote …
I didn’t try to infer that this cheapo $7 universal remote was the “super” mega ultimate solution that can learn everything on the planet, just that I believe that it covers more devices on the market than what Homey can…
Dissecting this universal remote is probably a whole seperate discussion on its own but from what I’ve seen those things are able to learn hundreds to maybe thousands of 433Mhz devices on the market, not just 6 or so …
I guess the big question is how many 433Mhz devices on the market does the Homey Pro currently support ? Is it in the hundreds or thousands or more ?
You also commented that this cheapo $7 universal remote “only” does fixed codes…. Isn’t that what “most” home devices use ?
Things such as garage controllers , security alarm systems, sliding gate controllers etc etc, do use proprietary rolling codes (also which are also encrypted).
Virtually no learning universal remote controls out there or smart hubs for that matter (not even Broadlink) can learn rolling codes… That type of equipment always locked down and requires some sort of “physical” hardwire hack or intervention to be able to control and isn’t accessible by 433Mhz .
Pointing out that this cheap $7 universal remote can “only” do fixed codes is sort of redundant as no other learning systems can learn rolling codes either…
Some people complain that the 433mhz gear they bought from a small low volume European manufacturer who uses crazy proprietary protocols and proprietary hardware wont work with a universal learning remote control.
Well that’s because they bought a device from a small low volume manufacturer that locks down their system with crazy proprietary protocol’s and hardware
What do you expect….
For 433Mhz gear in general my own golden rule is to always buy generic mass produced 433Mhz gear and never buy from small “boutique” or “exclusive” type of manufacturers … They just try to lock their systems down and make them in accessible…
I’m not “country” biased but Ive found many products made in European are generally locked down with proprietary protocols…
This may sound crazy but the more generic and cheaper the gear is ive generally found is more easier to deal with and take control of with universal remotes or smart hubs… From my experience generally anything you buy from AliExpress is fairly easy for RF learning systems to copy and re-transmit…
The Chinese really don’t care about locking their gear down or using fancy proprietary protocols or being “exclusive” … They just want the gear to be sellable to everyone. .(a good philosophy)
Anyhoo , my ramble has probably gone too long …(as usual)
My ultimate question is …(I’ve asked this many times now)
Homey is “able” to record RF raw code . Technically why can’t it play it back .?
I’m just looking for a technical definitive answer on that point otherwise all other talk is just a distraction to what everyone wants to really know ,…