First of all thank you so much with Self hosted server it makes even more options
Immediatelly installed it on my Mac mini at home.
I have a Homey Pro which is using z-wave, zigbee and thread, is there a way to migrate devices to Self hosted server yet? Would be awesome to be able to use the Homey pro as extender/z-wave/zigbee and other antennas for SHS.
Would be very cool and handy to move things from Homey X to SHS and keep specific things like z-wave/zigbee, aka use the Homey hardware as bridge and move things to SHS Thanks.
I would definitely like a way to migrate from HP23 to HSHS.
If it only were for flows, wifi devices, etc.
Not using Z-Wave, Zigbee (gor Z2M for that) and Thread here. And other ptorocols only very minimal.
@Emile and what about turning a HP2023 into a Homey bridge? (Also useful to know when buying an new HP2026). This would align Athom in responsable ecologic ethics to limit waste…
So i think it’s great there’s finally a SHS function! But i’m a little bit dissapointed….
I was noticing my Homey pro 2023 was more and more “offline” in the app where it was actually just running. And sometimes flows that always worked fine had sometimes hard times doing what they needed to do. Checked memory and there it was: 356.2 MB free
I’ve got a NAS that i could use for the SHS. More space but especially more RAM.
I almost switched to a new rpi board because of the memory issue untill this SHS announcement came. Great news!
My idea: keep all devices on the homey pro 2023 connected and move all other stuff, flows and apps, to the SHS.
Emile,
SHS is really a good idea but can’t be used by HomeyPro users who have spent hundreds of hours to tune their server. I, for one, have 2HomeyPros with 100+ devices and 50+ flows each and it is out of question that I redo the hard work to use SHS though I’d like so much to do so.
It’s OK. You like to focus on the negative and impossibilities as it seems (forumwide), I rather like to see what’s still possible given the circumstances.
That said:
Possibly the Flow Exchanger by Arie J. Godschalk is a better tool for this.
It can replace devices & variables on the fly during the import process.
Don’t get me wrong though, I don’t say a migration tool is not needed! But Athom usually takes one step at a time.
Maybe you recall there wasn’t a 2019 - 2023 migration possible at all at the Pro 2023 introduction. After many requests a migration possibility was built.
“Without the right to criticize, there can be no sincere praise.” (Beaumarchais, Le mariage de Figaro)
SHS is a one of the best things Athom has developped and your gracious comment would have hit the mark if it was not a paying version but a free alpha or beta version open to users suggestions about material extensions…
I don’t know to whom it is meant in its current state : It’s a complex solution if you’re a noob since you have to install the sofware and use a bridge which fails the purpose of having an independant server and is pretty limited. You’re better off buying a mini-HP.
One would have at least expected it open to external Zigbee, Zwave, Matter…controlers and/or using HP as a “bridge”…and I have no doubt Athom will provide those in future versions…and I don’t expect those who have spent months honing their HP’s devices and flows to undo their work in order to switch to a (current) limited server without proper external radio devices.
As to Arie’s tools, they do a life-saving job with a few flows/devices but are not tailored to tens of them and wouldn’t be of any use due to the current limitations (limitations of the bridge or having to rely on Homeylink which uses HP’s CPU and memory).
A migration tool is indeed needed as you mention but it won’t be enough if you have to rely on a bridge or HA to have it running
To sum up my first impressions about SHS : great innovation but lacking essential items in order to be on the market
Yeah agree with that. Hopefully they’ll allow you to use external dongles in the future without the need of the bridge. Homey pro and the bridge have poor zigbee performance imo.
You’re getting decent performance with the OS hosted on your own hardware but lacking the zigbee/zwave performance which is a shame.