I have one flow triggering a light when “any” of two zones become active (front of house and driveway). It works fine. I also have a flow for turning the light off when “all” zones has been inaktive for three minutes that doesn’t work at all. I fail to understand where my logic goes bad. [Skärm…

[image] PerJon: I fail to understand where my logic goes bad. Two different triggers for an ALL NEVER work! [image] [FAQ][Advanced Flow] Infinite canvas. Infinite creativity Two triggers to start an ALL Also applies to all other different triggers b̶e̶h̶i̶n̶d̶ before an ALL like “Someone…

Or in other words [Screenshot_20231123-184044_Chrome]

What probably is ment that the lights shall only go out when both zones are inactive. So there has to be a test that both zones are inactive.

Dear PerJon, That is a usual misconception many users had (including me). “All” does never work with different When… cards, as it only looks at the moment when one is triggered and does not wait for the other one. My proposal is that you connect the When… cards with Any and then check if both con…

Hi DirkH Something like this? [Skärmavbild 2023-12-11 kl. 21.53.26]

WHEN zone 1 is inactive for 3 minutes AND the zone 2 is inactive THEN ……… WHEN zone 2 is inactive for 3 minutes AND zone 1 is inactive THEN ……… [IMG_1667]

Hi @Wim_Post , yes, with only two triggers, your solution is more efficient. But in case you plan to add more devices, zones, or other triggers, it is easier to do it like the proposal from @PerJon . And Per yes that is what I was thinking about. But I guess you nedd to add an ALL card before It …

[image] DirkH: But I guess you nedd to add an ALL card before It isn’t between Dawn ( 0 ) and Dusk ( -30 ). I am not sure, how Homey Pro acts on the flow without that card. NEVER connect to inputs from an ALL on different triggers! That doesn’t work ! [image] [FAQ][Advanced Flow] Infinite…

[image] Dijker: NEVER connect to inputs from an ALL on different triggers! That doesn’t work ! Thank you Dijker, but I did not propose to connect triggers with ALL, but AND conditions What is wrong with this proposal? Well unless I would only turn off lights in the zones I checked, but just …

[image] DirkH: but I did not propose to connect triggers with ALL, but AND conditions What is wrong with this proposal? As drawn here perfect, maybe I interpreted your tip wrong. Guess I looked at the Edit @Wim_Post did and remove the ALL. Your ANY makes from 4 different Triggers one “N…

Flow with activity in several zones

Flows

Dijker November 23, 2023, 5:10pm 2

Two different triggers for an ALL NEVER work!

Topic		Replies	Views
How to setup a flow when you want two events to be true (at NOT the exact same time) Questions & Help advancedflow	9	424	October 24, 2024
All gates? Flows	8	69	February 23, 2026
Switching off a light with 2 sensors Flows homey-pro	2	622	July 30, 2023
WHY can we not have "zone has been (in)active for X" as an AND-card?! Flows	2	224	July 27, 2025
Kann mir bitte jemand helfen bei diesem simplen flow Fragen & Hilfe flow	8	165	July 11, 2024

Flow with activity in several zones

Related topics