That is great to see, thanks for sharing. Six roof planes is more than I can test on my own roof, so this tells me a lot, and it’s good to see the separate planes staying this close and not just the total.
If you feel like it, I’d like to know what the 7-day accuracy values on the device show.
since you’ve added electricity prices (which is a fantastic improvement!), would you consider supporting external electricity prices from other Homey apps/devices?
Unfortunately, Homey Energy doesn’t yet allow apps to supply custom electricity prices, although Athom is planning to support this:
My suggestion would be to add an External (Flow) price source, with two action cards:
Set current electricity price – accepts a numeric price per kWh.
Set electricity price schedule – accepts a JSON array of hourly or 15-minute prices for today/tomorrow.
Ideally, import and export prices could be provided separately.
Apps such as Power by the Hour already expose electricity prices and future price schedules through Flow tags, so users could simply pass these values to PV Forecast through Advanced Flows.
Or, maybe even easier, PV Forecast could allow users to select an existing Homey device and its electricity price capability, similar to how you already support selecting inverter and meter devices.
I noticed that your existing Find the cheapest start card already accepts external prices as JSON, so perhaps some of the necessary parsing logic is already there.
The main benefit would be reusing these prices across all PV Forecast functions, including battery planning, EV charging and negative-price handling, rather than only within one Flow calculation.
What do you think? Would this be technically feasible without introducing too much complexity?
On separate topic, also I tried today to set Bojler but getting this error, I believe I have all values correct ?
External prices: yes, that’s doable, and you’re right that the JSON parsing from Find the cheapest start can be reused. I’m thinking of a price source “From a Flow” with a card that takes the price schedule for today and tomorrow (hourly or per quarter, import and export separately). Then everything that uses prices follows it: the battery plan, car charging, appliances and negative prices. A current-price-only option from a device is easy to add too, but on its own it can’t plan ahead, so the schedule comes first. I’ll put it in the next feature version.
The heat buffer error: your values are fine, I checked them against the app’s own check. What fails is the step where the app makes sure the picked temperature and setpoint belong to that device, and the message didn’t say which part it didn’t like. Version 2.8.5 is live now and names the exact value and what Homey lists for that device. Could you update, try to save once more and post the new message here? And which app is the water heater from?
@Sharkys great, thanks for letting me know. If it ever comes back, the new message will say exactly what was missing.
@Peter_Kawa thanks, that’s a lovely set to see, and six planes tell me more than my own two. Planes 1 to 4 are about as close as I hoped.
About plane 5: the app learns its correction per position of the sun in the sky, not per hour of the day. So a fence, a tree or a house that blocks a patch of sky gets learned for exactly that patch. The low November sun moves through a part of the sky the app hasn’t seen much yet, so for now it leans on the neighbouring positions. It should come down over the next weeks without you doing anything, and next autumn it will already know.
Plane 6 looks like the chart was still loading in your screenshot. If it stays empty, could you post the device page or a diagnostics copy?
Thanks, that makes absolutely much sense. I won’t touch it.
My bad, you’re right.
I also discovered today this particular inverter wasn’t Wifi connected for a few weeks Reconnected, it actually does generate a little bit, see today’s graph:
@Peter_Kawa good find, and that explains the empty chart. Your 14-day view also shows the expected line kept its normal shape while the inverter was offline, so those weeks didn’t teach the app that plane 6 makes nothing.
@Sharkys yes, that helps, thanks. A plain list of 96 numbers is a day in quarters from midnight, and the app already reads that shape in Find the cheapest start, so the new price source will take it as it is. The plan is one card for today and one for tomorrow: run both from Power by the Hour with its “today” and “tomorrow” choice. “The next hours” has no times in it, so the app can’t tell where it starts; better to leave that one out. Prices are used as they come, without conversion, so keep them in the same currency as the rest of your setup.
@Sharkys version 2.9.0 has the price source I promised. It is in review now and goes live by itself once Athom approves it. Under Electricity prices, pick “From a Flow”. The new card “Set the electricity prices” takes the prices for today or tomorrow from any other app: one per hour or per quarter (24 or 96 numbers), buy and feed-in apart. It became one card with a choice for the day instead of two cards. The prices are used as they are, so put the taxes in them already.
Also new: if you set a price formula in Homey Energy, the app now uses it.
Thank you @weide43 , I tried to import prices from Power By The Hour, not sure if the names are the best, eg. buy and feed-in are confusing, better would be export/import I guess. No error reported but I don’t see option currently to check if the prices were imported alright.
Still, I assume feed-in is import price, yet even when set and run the flow, the app - for given forecast FVE instance, reports :
Thanks, that screenshot helped. Feed-in is the export price, what you get for power you send to the grid; buy is the import price. The card labels now say that too.
The prices from your Flow were stored, but your price source was still on Automatic, and the app only used them with the source “From a Flow”. Since Homey Energy has no dynamic prices for you, nothing was known. Two ways out: set the source under Electricity prices to “From a Flow” now, or wait for 2.9.1, which uses the Flow prices under Automatic whenever Homey Energy has none. 2.9.1 also shows under Electricity prices how many prices a Flow sent per day, so you can check the import. It is in review now and on the test channel.
Thanks, glad it helps! The house load is linked in the app settings, tab Measurement, a bit further down under “Consumption and home battery”. Under House consumption, pick a meter:
Grid meter (P1 or smart meter): the power your meter shows, positive when you take from the grid and negative when you send to it. The app adds the measured solar power to it to get what the house uses. If your meter counts the other way round, tick the box below it.
House consumption: a device that already shows what the whole house uses, solar included.
Then pick the device and its power value. After an hour of readings the first values appear, and the app learns the load per hour, apart for working days and weekend days and with the outdoor temperature. Once it is learned, the surplus and the plans for the battery, the car and the appliances take your own use into account. It works best when the solar power itself is also measured (linked inverter or Homey Energy, same tab).
That message means the app can’t connect to the Homey Web API on your Homey, and it needs that to read other devices such as a P1 meter. On a Homey Pro (Early 2023) or (2026) this normally works. On a Homey Pro (Early 2019) it doesn’t.
Which Homey do you have? If it’s a 2023 or 2026 model, please restart PV Forecast once (Settings > Apps > PV Forecast > Restart). If the message is still there afterwards, send a diagnostic report from the same page and tell me when you sent it, so I can see why the connection fails.
For now there’s no Flow card for the house load, only for production. I’ll look at adding a “Report house consumption” card for Homeys where the app can’t read devices directly.
Thanks, that explains the message. I was wrong about the Early 2019 in my last post, though. It can give the app access to your other devices; the app just didn’t ask for it on that model. I’ve changed that, and a test version is ready: https://homey.app/a/be.pvforecast/test/
After installing it, open the PV Forecast settings. The message should be gone, and you can pick your P1 meter under Measurement. Could you let me know if that works? You’d be the first to try it on an Early 2019.
If it still doesn’t work, the test version also has the card “Report house consumption”. Make a Flow with your P1 meter’s power changing as the trigger, then use that card with “grid meter power” and the power tag of the meter.