@Pro-Z A very good question indeed. Can you turn on debug in advanced settings and send me a debug report after?
Done and thanks in advance ![]()
4be469d7-1ab3-4039-8dff-c20b1fd05800
Did a quick look.
Logs didnt give much, all registers return garbage (or well, 0xFFFF), that’s what the app translates to -0.1. A couple of questions to just confirm.
- Is 10.0.0.21 the correct IP for the pump (check menu (7.5.x))? Do you have a ny other modbus devices on the network?
- Is Modbus TCP turned on in menu 7.5.9? If not that could explain it. restart the pump if you change it.
- Advanced settings → “Heat pump”: I expect it shows model 65535 rather than a real model code. That would confirm the identity read got
0xFFFFtoo.
Thanks for helping!
- Yes, yes I have many modbus devices on the network but only one connection to the heat pump, this one that I am trying to establish. I have until now used the NIBE S app for Homey by Jan Sparud but that one is disabled before I added the heat pump to NIBE Live. I had no issues in the Nibe S app.
- Yes
- The firmware and heat pump code shows 65535
Thanks! That rules out the obvious ones. 65535 everywhere means something answers at 10.0.0.21 but sends no heat pump data. Jan’s app connects exactly the way Nibe Live does, so I’ve added a diagnostic that checks what is actually at that address.
- Install test version 1.4.9: Nibe Live | Homey
- You can turn debug off. The diagnostic logs either way, and a shorter log is easier to read.
- Wait about 2 minutes after the update. The app checks the address and scans your network for other Modbus devices. The devices will now say “Something at 10.0.0.21 answers, but returns no heat pump data”. That’s expected.
- Send a new diagnostic report and post the ID here.
If you still have the old Nibe S app installed: which IP is in its device settings?
Thx, Done and done.
1fd9d3ee-9ce5-42b2-a2b9-f5f30dc72a70
The NIBE S app doesn’t show the IP in the settings for the user. I must double-check in the router settings but your app wouldn’t have “Find My Heat Pump” otherwise, right?
Well that was embarrassing. The IP actually points towards my solar inverter. Strange that the Nibe Live app finds it as a heat pump. I have added the heat pump manually with the correct IP which is 10.0.1.21 (in all haste I missrread 10.0.0.21 and now everything works. I’m so sorry for taking up your time with this!
No worries, I’ll try to figure out why it finds the wrong device.
Happy it works now!
The temperature gauge for the thermostat in NIBE heating doesn’t seem to do anything when checking the change with myUplink app? I don’t have a wired room temperature sensor connected to BT50. I only have NIBE wireless room temperature sensors.
Hey,
Thanks for reporting!
The Heating thermostat writes the zone 1 room setpoint (menu 1.1 on the pump). A wired BT50 isn’t needed: the wireless sensors control heating through their zone, so it should work with your setup. A few things would help me narrow it down:
- Which app version, pump model and firmware are you on?
- How many zones do you have, and which zone are your wireless sensors assigned to (room sensor/zone settings, menu 1.3)? The app currently only controls zone 1, so if your sensors are in another zone, that would explain it.
- Is Smart Price Adaption switched on? It can override the indoor setpoint.
- Change the target temperature in Homey and wait about 15 seconds. Does the value stay, or does it jump back? And what does menu 1.1 show on the pump’s own display? myUplink can lag behind.
- Right after that test, please send a diagnostics report (Homey app → Settings → Apps → Nibe Live → Create diagnostics report) and post the ID here.
Thanks!
- Nibe live 1.4.9, Nibe S 1156, firmware 4.14.6
- I have two zones with one room temperature sensor in each zone though it’s only zone 1 that controls the heating. In zone 2 the corresponding room temperature sensor only shows the temperature, it is not set to control the temperature.
- SPA is turned off, though Smart Room Control is on (automatically turns on when controlling the heat from a room temperature sensor from firmware version 4.0.10, it shouldn’t affect the set temperature)
- The temperature setting in Nibe Live does not revert within 15 seconds though I did notice, when I just checked, that the temperature had reverted back to 20°. After that I set it to 24° yesterday. Even so neither 20° nor 24° affects the heating setting on the heat pumps display in menu 1.1
Also the current temperature shows the median value between the two sensors. I have one room sensor in the basement and one on the ground floor, with 24.5°C on the ground floor and 22°C in the basement. The Nibe Live app shows 23.4°. Just like myUplink app it should only display the temperature of the room temperature sensors that control the heating imho.
Diagnostic report coming here: 3d09e778-19cb-4093-b47f-9bda1871aa10
Thanks!
Hi,
This explains a few things.. thanks!
Your setup is the first two-zone pump I’ve been able to look at closely. I can look at adding support for that, but before building anything, here’s how I’m thinking about it.
How Nibe does it. A climate system is a water circuit with one supply temperature. It can be split into zones, each with its own sensors and target temperature. Each zone works out how warm the water needs to be, and the pump uses the warmest of those requests for the whole circuit. A zone has no valve of its own, so raising one zone’s temperature warms the water for every room on that circuit, not just that room.
What I’m proposing. Because of that, I’d keep one Heating device per climate system rather than one per zone. A separate thermostat per zone would suggest you can heat the basement on its own, which the pump can’t do. For your setup, Heating would look like this:
Heating
├─ Thermostat: zone 1 (the zone that controls the heating)
│ current temperature = zone 1’s sensor only, no longer the average
│ target temperature = zone 1’s setting, the same as menu 1.1
└─ Zone 2 temperature (shown, not adjustable, since it only displays)
If several zones control the heating, one is the thermostat and the others get their own target temperature slider and Flow card. Zone 1 would be the default, changeable in Repair. If you have a second climate system (for example underfloor heating and radiators on separate circuits), that becomes its own Heating device.
What I’d like your view on:
- Does this match how you think about your house, or would you expect something else?
- Would you want zone 2 in Nibe Live at all, or is seeing its temperature in myUplink enough?
- Is there anything you do with zones in myUplink today that you’d want to automate in Homey?
How you could help. I need to find which settings on the pump belong to which zone. That’s why Nibe Live changed a setting that didn’t show up in menu 1.1. I’d send you a test version that only records what changes. You’d then change each zone’s temperature once on the pump, once in myUplink and once in Nibe Live, using unusual values like 21.5 and 18.5, and send a diagnostics report. It takes about ten minutes, and you’d put your normal settings back afterwards. Photos of menu 1.1 and the zone settings menu would help too.
No rush. Thanks for offering to help!
Hi!
You are quite correct and your proposal is exactly what I would want it to do.
- Yes
- It would be nice to see the temperature for each zone in NIBE Live. Then I can ditch myUplink.
- No, nothing more than to change the temperature for the controlling zone. That I can think of.
Sure I can help. I can’t find a new test version though. Have you released it? For your information I can only change the temperature on the heat pump for zones that actively controls the heat.
But I think I have already figured it out for you when I fiddled with the settings. Apparently zone 1 (named Källarplan) is the zone that I don’t control and zone 2 (named Entreplan) is the zone that I do control. When I tested to activate the room temperature sensor for zone 1 to control the heating, then I can change that temperature setting with Nibe Live. So to boil it down, zone 1 works already in NIBE Live to control the heat, but the displayed current heat shows an average of zone 1 and zone 2 (which is a bit misleading since the set temperature only uses zone 1). It’s just that I’m using zone 2 to control the heat, and that is why it does not work to control the heat from Nibe Live as of now.
If it helps I could just rename zone 1 and zone 2 to the opposite and move the controlling sensors for each zone so that I am actually controlling zone 1. But the current temperature should only show zone 1 not an average. As I mentioned earlier it would be nice to also be able to see the temperature for zone 2 inside the Nibe heating device.
Tell me if there is something I need to clarify or more I can do to help.
Thanks!
Thanks for figuring out your zones. This test version uses what you found.
What’s new:
- Choose the zone the thermostat sets. Open Heating → Repair → Heating Setup. The first question is “Which zone should the thermostat set?” Pick Zone 2 (Entreplan). Zones are numbered in the same order as on the pump, so Zone 1 is Källarplan.
- Zone temperature scan. About two minutes after the app starts, it reads through your pump’s registers to find where each zone’s temperature is stored. It only reads, nothing is changed, and it takes a few minutes.
What hasn’t changed yet: the current temperature on the thermostat is still the average of both zones, and Källarplan isn’t shown in Nibe Live yet. Both come in the next version, once the scan has found the right registers.
How you can help:
- Install 1.4.10 (test version): Nibe Live | Homey
- Heating → Repair → Heating Setup: choose Zone 2 and save.
- Change the temperature in Nibe Live and check that Entreplan follows in menu 1.1 on the pump.
- Restart the app (Settings → Apps → Nibe Live → Restart). About two minutes later, note what myUplink shows for Källarplan and Entreplan, with one decimal if possible.
- Wait about 10 minutes, then send a diagnostics report and post the ID here with the two temperatures.
Thanks again, this is really helping!
Great!
Done and done. Zone 1 temperature in myUplink: 22°. Zone 2: 24.4°.
0d0c1e37-f679-4c7a-b886-6fb972ee390c
EDIT: Oops I forgot to change the temperature in Nibe Live before I send the diagnostic report. I can confirm that a change of temperature now works on the heat pump. Do you need a new diagnostic report?
Thanks again for the report, the scan worked! It found two registers that match your sensors: one reads 22.0 (Källarplan) and the other 24.8 (Entreplan). Their average is exactly the 23.4 Nibe Live shows today.
One thing I need to check before the next version. Nibe added these registers for wireless units, so they may follow the order your sensors were added rather than the zone order. Could you check this?
- Go to menu 5.4 (wireless units) on the pump. In what order are your room sensors listed? Is the Entreplan sensor first or second?
- Are there any other wireless units in that list, such as a room unit or another accessory?
A photo of the screen works great. Thanks!
No problem, great!
- Entreplan is second in order
- No other devices
New test version 1.4.11 is out. What’s new:
- The thermostat can show one sensor’s temperature instead of the average of both.
- Each wireless sensor gets its own temperature row on the Heating device, so you can see Källarplan in Nibe Live too.
To set it up:
- Update to 1.4.11: [link to the test version]
- Open Heating → Repair → Heating Setup.
- Keep Zone 2 for the thermostat.
- Under the temperature source, pick the Wireless room sensor that reads about 24–25 °C. That’s Entreplan.
- Save.
Please check:
- The thermostat shows Entreplan’s temperature, matching myUplink.
- The Heating device has two “Wireless room sensor” rows. One should read about 22 °C (Källarplan) and the other the same as Entreplan.
Sadly Nibe seems to have no clear order of how the wireless sensors map to a zone, so I’e just added them as “Wireless sensors” for now.
Thanks. Everything seems to be working as intended now ![]()
Great, I’ve submitted a 1.5.0 with a bunch of smaller fixes, and your Zone support included.
Any other ideas for the app more than welcome!